Helping you understand insurance is our top priority

We want to help make the process of buying insurance simple and understandable so you can get back to enjoying your life!

Our process is simple

Start online, and we'll reach
out to complete your coverage comparison.

At Mathenia Insurance Group, we understand! Insurance Can Be Overwhelmingly Confusing. All Of The Jargon, Terms, And Coverages Can Make You Feel Like You Don't Understand Any Of It. Our Team Educates Our Clients So They Fully Understand What Their Premium Dollars Are Being Spent On.

  • Start Online

    Enter basic info on our website

  • We Compare Carriers

    We shop multiple carriers for you

  • You Choose

    Pick the coverage package you like best

Our friendly & knowledgable team is our greatest competitive advantage.

What makes one insurance agency different from all the rest? Simple - people, personality, and professionalism. At Mathenia Insurance Group, we go above and beyond to ensure your experience with us is one you won't forget.

Personal & Commercial Insurance Simplified

At Mathenia Insurance Group we have access to a wide range of both insurance carriers and products. This gives us, and more importantly, you, flexibility and choice when it comes to your coverages and company.

Personal Insurance

Whether its home, auto, renters, boat or umbrella  we can help protect you and your family with custom coverages.

Commercial Insurance

We protect hundreds of businesses, from large to small.  We've got you covered.

Specialty Insurance

Things like unoccupied or vacant properties don't fit standard carrier programs, but we've got the solution.

Screen Shot 2022-12-15 at 5.49.46 PM
Screen Shot 2022-12-15 at 5.38.12 PM

A simpler, faster solution to your insurance

We find the best solutions for our clients not the best clients for our solutions.

Call Email Quote Payments